Last Friday Victorian Labor promised bold action on something they had refused to do much for in their first decade in office from 2014. Metropolitan train frequencies. Cities like Sydney, Perth and latterly even Auckland surpassed Melbourne on rail frequencies while Melbourne's train timetables remained stubbornly stagnant.
Context
Outside a few privileged lines, 20, 30 and even 40 minute gaps remained the norm outside peak periods. This made our peak-heavy network particularly vulnerable to the pandemic patronage collapse and the only partial recovery afterwards as working from home became more accepted.
Context
Outside a few privileged lines, 20, 30 and even 40 minute gaps remained the norm outside peak periods. This made our peak-heavy network particularly vulnerable to the pandemic patronage collapse and the only partial recovery afterwards as working from home became more accepted.
Timetables at most stations were inconvenient for anyone other than the diminishing number of five day 9-5 CBD workers. You only needed to travel slightly at times slightly outside the commuter norm, for instance to drop kids off at school, to be caught by gaps of 20 and sometimes nearer to 30 minutes. The message conveyed was: "If you are not a weekday peak CBD commuter your time is not important".
A transport policy agenda based on respecting peoples' time, getting the most from assets and maximising value for money includes everything from responsive pedestrian crossings, bike paths, direct bus routes to trains that run frequently all day. Some require large new infrastructure but most do not.
New promises
Labor's approach to 2024 had been to prioritise its "Big Build" over everything else, including smaller projects, maintenance and operations. It was easier to borrow $10b for a megaproject than to find a small fraction of that to rid the Metro rail network of 30 and 40 minute gaps. Bus reform didn't get much of a go either with bus reform plan promises made in 2022 only to be broken after that election had been won.
A transport policy agenda based on respecting peoples' time, getting the most from assets and maximising value for money includes everything from responsive pedestrian crossings, bike paths, direct bus routes to trains that run frequently all day. Some require large new infrastructure but most do not.
New promises
Labor's approach to 2024 had been to prioritise its "Big Build" over everything else, including smaller projects, maintenance and operations. It was easier to borrow $10b for a megaproject than to find a small fraction of that to rid the Metro rail network of 30 and 40 minute gaps. Bus reform didn't get much of a go either with bus reform plan promises made in 2022 only to be broken after that election had been won.
The 2025 state budget started to give some attention to improved service levels. A bit more came in the 2026 budget. Mounting budget pressures, the corruption royal commission in full swing and a new premier differentiating himself from his (same party) predecessors swung Labor's sentiment even further from major infrastructure.
In transport this has meant that service rather than infrastructure has dominated the party's promises in 2026. This includes $400m each for major bus and V/Line rail service upgrades in Melbourne's west.
More modest ($100m) but arguably bigger (in terms of patronage) is the November 13 promise for off-peak trains on much of the hitherto underserved Clifton Hill and Burnley groups. These improve Monday to Sunday frequencies to every 10 minutes until 7pm on four (not five) lines. A graphic from their advertising is below.
In transport this has meant that service rather than infrastructure has dominated the party's promises in 2026. This includes $400m each for major bus and V/Line rail service upgrades in Melbourne's west.
More modest ($100m) but arguably bigger (in terms of patronage) is the November 13 promise for off-peak trains on much of the hitherto underserved Clifton Hill and Burnley groups. These improve Monday to Sunday frequencies to every 10 minutes until 7pm on four (not five) lines. A graphic from their advertising is below.
The promised 10 minute service is to Mernda, Greensborough, Ringwood and Glen Waverley so Labor's graphic oversells it. However it's still a major lift that more than doubles the number of stations with 7 day 10 minute service as per the animation below (click for better view).
Council areas to benefit including Boroondara, Whitehorse, Maroondah, Monash, Knox, Stonnington, Yarra, Whittlesea, Darebin, Banyule and Yarra. These amount to 1.7 million people. Or about one-third of Melbourne and bigger than Adelaide (1.5m). Relative to existing payments to Metro, the $100m price tag represents good value for the freedom of being able to travel without a timetable.
This concept is not dissimilar to that proposed by Jan Scheurer to reverse the decline in per capita public transport service intensity as measured by SNAMUTS. Both ideas deliver 10 minute service to Mernda, Ringwood and Glen Waverley. The difference is that Labor's plan upgrades service on the Hurstbridge line (as far as Greensborough) instead of Craigieburn.
This concept is not dissimilar to that proposed by Jan Scheurer to reverse the decline in per capita public transport service intensity as measured by SNAMUTS. Both ideas deliver 10 minute service to Mernda, Ringwood and Glen Waverley. The difference is that Labor's plan upgrades service on the Hurstbridge line (as far as Greensborough) instead of Craigieburn.
Which lines aren't part of this promise?
The Pakenham, Cranbourne, Frankston, Sandringham and Sunbury lines aren't covered but they are either already frequent or have received major recent upgrades. Werribee, Upfield and Craigieburn have received smaller recent upgrades. Craigieburn passengers especially will be disappointed that this upgrade doesn't cover them given the line's high usage and expectations previously raised.
Who originated this plan?
The Pakenham, Cranbourne, Frankston, Sandringham and Sunbury lines aren't covered but they are either already frequent or have received major recent upgrades. Werribee, Upfield and Craigieburn have received smaller recent upgrades. Craigieburn passengers especially will be disappointed that this upgrade doesn't cover them given the line's high usage and expectations previously raised.
Who originated this plan?
While this is a Labor promise in 2026, the concept of off-peak trains every 10 minutes was supported by then Shadow Transport Minister David Hodgett in 2017. 2017 also saw the Berejiklian Coalition government in NSW boost many suburban train frequencies from 30 to 15 minutes on much of the Sydney network.
But it was the Baillieu Coalition government that released a plan in 2013 to get all main lines in Melbourne to 10 minute frequencies (with branches every 20 minutes or better). This was consistent with major rail frequency improvements that government implemented, including weekend trains every 10 minutes to Ringwood, Dandenong and Frankston. 14 years prior to that the Kennett government boosted weekday off-peak trains to Dandenong and Frankston from 20 to 15 minutes.
Thus while the current Labor government introduced 10 minute off-peak frequency on the Sunbury line, more frequent Metro train services is a policy that, if it wanted to, the Liberal side could claim ownership and support for given its past record. Coalition support is essential given all opinion polls point to a Labor loss.
In electoral terms the eastern Belgrave/Lilydale/Glen Waverley lines are particularly significant as these are traditional Liberal strongholds that are expected to return after Labor won many of these seats in its large 2018 and 2022 victories. A Coalition victory may also include some Hurstbridge line seats being won.
But it was the Baillieu Coalition government that released a plan in 2013 to get all main lines in Melbourne to 10 minute frequencies (with branches every 20 minutes or better). This was consistent with major rail frequency improvements that government implemented, including weekend trains every 10 minutes to Ringwood, Dandenong and Frankston. 14 years prior to that the Kennett government boosted weekday off-peak trains to Dandenong and Frankston from 20 to 15 minutes.
Thus while the current Labor government introduced 10 minute off-peak frequency on the Sunbury line, more frequent Metro train services is a policy that, if it wanted to, the Liberal side could claim ownership and support for given its past record. Coalition support is essential given all opinion polls point to a Labor loss.
In electoral terms the eastern Belgrave/Lilydale/Glen Waverley lines are particularly significant as these are traditional Liberal strongholds that are expected to return after Labor won many of these seats in its large 2018 and 2022 victories. A Coalition victory may also include some Hurstbridge line seats being won.
How would this 10 minute plan fit in with pending upgrades?
While the first 10 of Victorian Labor's 12 years in office did not deliver much for Metro (as opposed to V/Line) rail frequencies, their recent record, thanks to funding in the 2025 and 2026 state budgets, is better. The table below shows pending, Labor promised and to be funded upgrades.
On the other hand some of the unfunded measures (notably boosting Sunday mornings from 30 to 20 minutes and pushing the start of 30 minute evening service back to 9 or 10pm) are more modest so may be possible earlier. This could be consistent with a staged approach and remove sharp service cliffs such as particularly exist on the Belgrave and Lilydale lines where ~10 minute frequencies can collapse to 30 minutes in a short period. That group's complex peak timetable is also worth reviewing to reduce the number of stopping patterns but to have frequent service on each one.
A reorganising of priorities after the election is something that one would expect a new incoming government to do. It is essential to keep an eye on altered priorities to ensure that the good (but incomplete) off-peak rail service upgrades funded in the 2026 state budget in the pnding column still proceed.
Conclusion
Labor has proposed beneficial package of off-peak train frequency upgrades for five lines, arguably inspired by an old plan from a previous Liberal government. These are economical and maximise use of existing assets and infrastructure.
Not being dependent on either level crossing removals or the Metro Tunnel, they should have been done years ago. But they weren't due to the "infrastructure first" approach of previous premiers and ministers.
The second best time to do them is now so it would be highly desirable that should it win government the Coalition draw inspiration from past achievements in rail service and match or beat Labor's rail frequency offer.
Not being dependent on either level crossing removals or the Metro Tunnel, they should have been done years ago. But they weren't due to the "infrastructure first" approach of previous premiers and ministers.
The second best time to do them is now so it would be highly desirable that should it win government the Coalition draw inspiration from past achievements in rail service and match or beat Labor's rail frequency offer.




No comments:
Post a Comment