Thursday, May 04, 2023

UN 152: Transport for Mambourin

Take the train from Melbourne towards Geelong. Look right towards the YouYangs a couple of minutes after you depart Wyndham Vale Station. You will see lots of houses. That's Mambourin.

Their local station at Black Forest Rd is neither funded nor built. While a cruel tease for now its appearance on some maps may build expectations that cause it to eventually happen. But for now, like many new estates, service provision is lagging with not even a local bus route serving a now populated area. 

The nearest bus stop is 30 minutes walk away. Like at Mt Atkinson, locals are campaigning for a local service with a 'bus marathon' held last month. Mambourin is in the state seat of Werribee, held by Treasurer Tim Pallas.  

Mt Atkinson, discussed last week, was quite difficult to draw a bus route concept for. I presented several potential alignments, each with its pros and cons. Fortunately better planned Mambourin looks easier with a potential through route between two major stations. 

The first, and most easily resolved question, was whether an existing route could be extended. That would be the most economical way of improving coverage if this was possible.

The only route in the area is the 192 between Werribee and Wyndham Vale. That has a lot of unique coverage and is a good patronage performer. So it's best left alone and a new route added for Mambourin. 

Desirable features of such a new route include: 

* Connectivity to trains on both lines in the area (Geelong and Werribee)
* Good access to the nearest shopping centre (and preferably others)
* Good coverage of residential areas with reasonable directness
* Potential to feed trains at a future station at Black Forest Rd
* An efficient route length for a frequency that harmonises with trains

Mapped below is a rough concept for something that might reasonably satisfy these points. I've called it the 193 given that its nearest existing route is the 192. 


It feeds trains at both Wyndham Vale and Werribee, serves local shops and provides reasonable (though not complete) coverage. Its 12-13 km length should take a little under 40 minutes.

A very basic service every 40 minutes (meshing with off-peak trains at both stations) would require two buses while four buses would be required for a more attractive 20 minute frequency (which a lot more routes in Wyndham should have - all day - due to strong patronage). 

If the cheaper 40 minute option is chosen it is desirable that timetables are offset with those for Route 192 (also every 40 min off-peak) to provide a combined 20 minute frequency on common portions.   

That's the concept anyway. The actual alignment might be different, depending on roads that are open and where further housing has been built by the time that service starts. 

Thoughts on all this are appreciated and can be left below. 

Index to other Building Melbourne's Useful Network items 

Note: From now on I will post on Thursdays instead of Fridays. This should widen readership and discussion on a day of the week where influential readers are more likely to be in their offices with colleagues rather than working from home.   

3 comments:

TramMaestro said...

What about an extension of Route 441 (serving Westleigh Gardens) renumbered as 193? There are estates along Alfred Rd and at Riverwalk which have this outdated route and timetable (40 min peak, 60 min offpeak, 6am to 8pm span) from the pre-reform Wyndham network which is ripe for an upgrade given the development and future arterial planned (Ison Rd).

Taking the 193 north of the rail line not only duplicates the 192 which takes care of the area between Werribee station and Black Forest Road, it also doesn’t help new communities south of the rail line have a decent connection to external transport in their area.

My idea for the 193 would follow the 441 until Dutchelm Ave/Newmarket Rd (given the poor connectivity of Westleigh Gardens), then follow Timbara, Coldstone, Alfred, Browns, and Galvin, before reaching Bulban and then following your route. Running at a 40 min frequency (unideal as you say) would still permit a combined 20 min corridor along Armstrong Rd towards Wyndham Vale station.

Peter Parker said...

Possibly. Though there may remain areas in Riverwalk that need coverage. Maybe keep the 441 as a local but have the 193 as being their direct route along Geelong Rd, then Alfred etc?

Anonymous said...

It's a little difficult to read the map but I can't see a stop up the north-end of Black Forest Rd. I see a lot of primary and secondary school students walking from there to the nearest but stop on Haines Ave which is at least 20mins walk. My main concern is the safety of the children walking along the bridge on Black Forest Rd.