Saturday, July 01, 2023

40 years since The Met (Was it any good?)

Today marks 40 years since transport was organisationally reformed in Melbourne. Metropolitan train, tram and government bus operations were united under the Metropolitan Transit Authority from July 1, 1983. This was one of four new transport authorities set up by the Cain government. 


These reforms could be seen as a continuation of the trend towards ministerial control of the transport network. While transport and politics had always been intertwined, declining patronage and rising costs meant that fares could no longer fund operations (let alone capital improvements) and services required government subsidy after about 1970. 

State funding always comes with strings attached. In this case it was a desire for political control (in the name of things like 'the public interest', 'accountability' and 'efficiency' or less stated political ends like looking after marginal seats). Associated organisational changes can affect the relative profile and power of various people within the transport hierarchy. 

Hence, much like how police commissioners are household names, 60 years ago everyone knew who Robert Risson (Tramways Board Chairman) was. Whereas in 2023 few can name DTP's Secretary (Paul Younis), Metro CEO (Raymond O'Flaherty) and Yarra CEO (Carla Purcell), but Transport minister Jacinta Allan is recognised by all. Back in 1982-83 incoming minister Steve Crabb sought a similarly high profile as a big-promising 'Mr Fix it' with organisational changes reducing the autonomy of the old modally-based rail and tram bodies. 

The appetite for change in 1982 was high due to transport's then poor state. While there was a revival of government interest in public transport in the first half of premier Hamer's time (including the arrival of Hitachi trains, new trams and City Loop construction) this gave way to a decline after about 1978 (including strikes, service cuts, line closures and the unpopular Lonie Report). Network patronage was also falling, hitting rock-bottom around 1981.

A public backlash to the Lonie report (which wanted to cut basically all regional rail) and an election looming led the Hamer/Thompson government to change tack in 1981. That year's New Deal for Country Passengers started the reversal of fortunes on the busier regional lines and there were some bus upgrades in 1982 (interestingly the exact same recipe for Steve Bracks/Peter Batchelor with other modes neglected).  The public did not seem convinced by the 27-year old government's latter-day conversion. Public transport was still a big negative for the Liberals with John Cain's Labor opposition promising a big revival.  

The new Cain government, with Steve Crabb as Transport Minister, introduced the Transport Act 1983. This was transport reform's enabling legislation. More about it and further subsequent restructuring  here. 


Industrial relations

As everyone was only too well aware, industrial relations could make or break public transport. Even someone being rude in the lunch room could stop the trains. While older Melburnians romanticise tram conductors and pre-privatisation Met-era trains, the truth is that service was pretty mediocre in the 1980s with cancellations higher than now. Much was due to industrial disputation with accounts of disruptions published in PTUA newsletters of the time. 

Unions in those days were not just after pay and conditions but also wanted a big say in how things were done. This 'Me and The Met' video shows how management (led by American Lynn Strouse) sold organisational and other change to its workers. 

As a former managing director of Hertz Rent-a-car, Strouse brought transport (but not public transport) experience to the MTA managing director role. He didn't last long, resigning in 1985. The same could be said for his successor Mr K Shea from the Road Traffic Authority. These appointments may indicate a dissatisfaction by government with existing railway or tramway managers, with a preference for leaders with automotive or roads backgrounds.  


Fares


In theory The Met was multimode, even if operations were mostly still not.

Achievements in multimodality included unified livery, improved passenger information and a new neighbourhood-based fare system. That continued the multimode principle of the previous concentric three zone TravelCard system with time-based tickets allowing free transfers. However neighbourhood fares made Melbourne a patchwork of fare zones with numerous ticket combinations. All it did was to add complexity for little extra revenue as relatively few people made long orbital trips. Hence in 1989 Melbourne reverted to three radial zones but with slightly different boundaries to what operated under TravelCard. The popular time-based feature with free transfers (which contributed to increased usage on all modes) was retained. 

Subsequent fare changes in the 2000s, 2010s and 2020s made fares almost independent of distance, firstly across Melbourne and then across the state. These were all done because politicians see greater returns from cutting fares than boosting service. However the almost flat fare system makes it possible to simultaneously (and reasonably) complain that very short trips cost too much while long distance travel is outrageously cheap. 


Controversy and achievements

The Met era was not free of controversy. Plans to convert railway lines to St Kilda, Port Melbourne and Upfield to trams (or 'light rail') faced opposition, and in Upfield's case was not carried out. Few of Labor's bold 1982 promises to build or extend lines were honoured though some lines (eg Stony Point) were reopened.

Some of what was done was a case of 'two steps forward, two steps back', for instance the routing of previously fast Werribee trains via the slow Altona section when the line to Laverton was completed. Werribee people had to wait decades for their all-day direct service to be restored, though this has only been partial, with weekend and evening services continuing to operate the slow way via Altona in 2023. 


The Met period is also associated with the full completion of the City Loop, the roll-out of A and B class trams and delivery of air conditioned Comeng trains. The latter is significant as air conditioning  went from being a rare luxury to a standard feature in private cars during the 1980s and 90s. There were also some rail infrastructure upgrades such as overhead renewals and Frankston line's third track to Moorabbin which allowed more expressing. 

Train services

Trains were largely considered peak commuter transit. There wasn't much interest in increasing off-peak service frequencies (nor even of reversing the 1978 cuts to evening frequencies).

At this time the typical Melbourne train line ran every 20 minutes Monday - Saturday off-peak, every 30 minutes Monday - Saturday evening and every 40 minutes on Sunday (with a later start and earlier finish than on other days of the week).

Met-era train frequencies compared poorly with what Perth was rolling out in its early 1990s electrification with their weekday interpeak frequencies improving to every 15 minutes (which later got extended to 7 days and into the early evening).    

Trams generally were more frequent but remained with less service than 30 years prior. 


Multi-mode planning

With the railways running their evening trains typically every 30 minutes (after the 1978 cuts) and the tramways preferring 20 minute evening frequencies, there was no timetable co-ordination between modes in pre-Met times, with the best connections recurring only hourly.

Despite the organisational changes and the rhetoric, The Met didn't walk the walk when it came to the nuts and bolts of service planning, especially across modes. This is unlike what Perth was doing in the early 1990s when it was designing its feeder bus network to harmonise with the new Joondalup line.

The Met experience shows that although you can have on-paper unification modes will continue to operate as separate fiefdoms unless there is a determination to bring a network perspective to service planning and harmonise timetables. Some opportunities to weave a network were taken but too many were missed during The Met era, such as short tram extension where they stopped short of stations. 

Box Hill was The Met's showpiece when it came to physically integrating train and bus connectivity. It was good for those getting to the shops but weaker for connectivity between modes. With the trains at the bottom and buses three flights of stairs above (with a shopping centre in the middle) it did not make for the fast and direct interchange that such a major transfer point ought to have. Other states were doing better at the time, having recently built efficient train-bus interchanges at locations such as Sydney's Bondi Junction, Adelaide's Noarlunga and Perth's Kelmscott. 


Bus planning

Melbourne's two-tier bus network continued through the Met era. For example main routes inherited from the Tramways ran frequently over wide tram-type operating hours. Whereas privately operated routes rarely operated on Sundays or even Saturday afternoons. Despite operating hours improvements since, stark differences in service levels, even on routes that ought to be comparable, remain to this day.    

The mid-1980s saw reviews of bus networks in areas like Moorabbin. There was still a large number of short routes but small private bus operators were gradually merging or being bought by large operators. 

Older areas (often losing population) had bus routes very closely spaced while growth areas lacked service. Bus resources tended to be shifted to growth areas with inner area frequencies reduced. Some people gained but in other cases buses became a less attractive 'last mile' option for commuters beyond walking distance of a station.

Trading hours were widening with Saturday afternoon shopping, especially at major centres, becoming more common. Buses then often ran a frequent Saturday morning service but ceased operating after midday. 1987 bus timetable changes added Saturday afternoon service to many bus routes as well as some later evening trips. This was a major upgrade program, benefiting 85 bus routes (out of a 250-300 network total). You could say it was a precursor to the 2006 Meeting Our Transport Challenges plan which implemented even better upgrades on more routes. 

The rise

V/Line was doing well while Melburnians loved their new air conditioned trains as Red Rattlers became rarer and rarer. Trams extended further north while growth areas gained new bus routes. Patronage across all modes revived from its 1981 nadir as unemployment fell from 1984. There did seem to be some feeling of progress. Confidence peaked in 1988 with minister Kennan writing an optimistic introduction to that year's Met Plan (more on that here). He said that the 'atmosphere of decline and decay' was over and the only way was up. 

The fall

That MetPlan introduction proved to be the hubris before the fall. That fall was fast, hard and long. So long that almost none of MetPlan got done in its 15 year term and service actually went backwards.

Victoria was the hardest hit state of the 1990s recession as manufacturing industries closed and people left for Queensland. Unemployment surged and state finances were parlous due to the VEDC and Pyramid scandals and reduced revenue generally. Affiliated unions (including in transport) would not accept cuts proposed by the Labor government. The government sold and leased back trains and trams to pay its bills. Decline and decay were back. Big time. 

Not all transport problems were related to or started when the state's economy soured.  

For example political and industrial relations between the publicly moderate Cain government and the broader militant left-wing movement had long been toxic. There were times where ministers appeared like ineffectual teachers facing a rowdy classroom. Controversies existed over the Upfield line's future, numerous strikes, ticketing and staffing issues. Background on some of this activism here.

What might  have been seen as public transport's ungovernability could have made ministers throw up their hands in despair and warm to the (mostly incorrect) hope that franchising out operations would transfer risk and responsibility to others. This may have been one reason why Victoria was more eager than other states to franchise out trains and trams even though it didn't necessarily end up saving much money.  

The MTA was also its own worst enemy with regards to bus contracting in 1988. Mis-steps led to protracted litigation (the Waverley Transit case) that private operators won. This resulted in the government paying Quinces to start running long highly duplicative routes across the eastern suburbs (631 and 634) at short notice. These were called 'Metlink' routes but they had little in common with the more direct 'Metlink' routes in MetPlan that were more like the orbital SmartBuses we eventually got about 20 years later.

During this time transport went through another organisational restructure, with the MTA and STA merging to become the Public Transport Corporation (PTC). In 1990 and 1991 PTC cut funding to private bus operators. This resulted in massive cuts to peak, after 7pm and weekend buses across Melbourne. That effectively undid a lot of the 1987 upgrades if not more. Timetables were not to recover for another 20 years if they did at all. An example of the latter was the 800 bus along Princes Hwy between Dandenong and Chadstone. This saw all Sunday, all evening and most Saturday trips cut in 1991. Despite high usage and development since, the reduced timetable remains, almost unaltered, in 2023. 

Most famously was Jim Kennan's 'scratch tickets' debacle that made paying fares optional as the government sought to remove tram conductors. Industrial disputes clogged the city with trams while surging cancellations made catching trains a gamble. A Kennan vs Mees (PTUA) debate appears here: 



Staffing at stations was being reduced, especially outside peaks. Evening train usage was so low that sometimes only the front carriage was open for passengers. There was a vandalism and graffiti epidemic with concerns about personal safety rife. TISM's Mourningtown Ride was one product of this era.  



By 1991 public transport in Melbourne was at a low ebb, like it was a decade earlier. Many patronage gains were lost as train, tram and bus service deteriorated. While raw usage was still higher in 1991 than it was in 1981, modal share was at a record low as population had grown. 


(Direct YouTube link if video above doesn't show - 1989-90 news reports)

Politics and aftermath

Around this time having political responsibility for public transport was a poisoned chalice. This is especially under a Labor government where there were unmeetable expectations from unions and, to some extent, the public (which Labor itself fanned though promises made). Transport ministers in this era tended not to last for long. For instance the 10 year Cain-Kirner period saw 4 ministers (Crabb, Roper, Kennan, Spyker). Only Crabb and Spyker remain alive today with Roper's state funeral in a few days. 

Labor lost the 1992 election with the state still deep in recession. Some regional lines were closed under Jeff Kennett. There was also the threat of metropolitan closures and permanent evening bus replacements but these were staved off.

Minister Alan Brown presided over a major cost-cutting program that was easier for a Liberal government to do as the premier and minister could be firm with unions without threatening factional relationships and thus their positions. Brown, possibly the most competent transport minister for many years, almost comes across as a hero figure in wanting to retain and extend trams at a time Alan Reiher, the state's top transport bureaucrat, wanted to close them. Mooted severe cuts for the metropolitan rail network were avoided. However ticketing was to remain a problem for this and successor governments with Metcard costing more and taking longer than envisaged.

Staffing numbers were cut but the loss of services in transport was perhaps not as severe as that more wider occurring school and hospital closures. By about 1997 things had settled down with fewer cancellations, the Upfield line saved and interpeak train frequency increases on lines in the south-east. Trams that ran as buses on Sundays got 7 day service restored and NightRider buses started. Possibly parliament's longest ever speech on public transport was given by Robin Cooper in 1996 detailing that government's achievements. 

Just before it left office the Kennett government introduced the biggest ever increase in Sunday service increases across the train and tram networks. Over 20 years later the current government has yet to implement any across-the-network metropolitan service increase of comparable size. 

Those upgrades were for trains and trams. But bus services were largely neglected during the Kennett era. 1990s growth areas like Rowville and Lysterfield didn't even get a basic hourly local bus service, with their situation remaining basically unchanged 30 years later. Some existing routes got reduced service but the cuts were not as deep as in the previous two years under Labor.   

Met buses got franchised (ie privatised) in two tranches with National Bus and Melbourne Bus Link taking over in 1993 and 1998 respectively. Trams and trains followed later. The latter was operationally disruptive as the government unwisely sought to split one train network into two in an effort to play operators against one another. (as is received competition theory). The incoming private operators ran reliable services  between 2000 and 2003 but hoped for cost savings did not happen, having bid too low. More on that era here. 

As you might  have gathered, late 1990s transport policy was all about transport franchising. That is, as a Marxist would say, the means of production rather than the product or service itself. The Met's dismantling was overseen by a 'Transport Reform Unit' in Treasury that, like early 20th century railway moguls, saw modes and operators as competitors against one another rather than as part of a connected network. Hence aspects of multimodalism, such as common signage, liveries and multimode maps, that were achieved under The Met were removed (or left to rot) as the new structures simply had no one properly responsible (The then Department of Infrastructure at the time being notoriously lazy on this).


Under franchising there was just one government job in transport, and that was to manage a series of private contracts that periodically get retendered. The assumption that this could transfer political risk proved incorrect, as the Brumby government found. As did the one about having franchisees independently plan acceptable networks as we saw in 2015 with Transdev.

Similar ideologies survive today in the more doctrinaire corners of Infrastructure Victoria who believes that public transport modes should compete rather than connect, aided by differential modal fares that undermine efficient network planning (including the bus network reform that IV otherwise purports to back). 

At the worst depths of this lunacy we saw trains and stations with maps showing only 'their' half of the network (ie Bayside or Hillside). And there was the farce of trains continually being rebranded at the drop of a hat. The network became less legible with information either fragmented or falling to pieces.

Deluded operators thought that there were heaps of potential cost savings there for the taking and if you rebranded a train patronage would rise to meet the levels their ambitious bids were based on. Neither happened and operators made penny-pinching short-cuts (eg National Express not training new drivers).

In the first clue that they had to think like a passenger and see the network as a whole, panicking private operators got together to form the Metropolitan Passenger Growth Initiative. This would become Metlink (technically an operator owned company) and provide multimodal passenger information and network marketing. This period coincided with rising patronage driven by booming CBD employment, higher fuel costs and bus service upgrades associated with 2006's MOTC plan. 

In short Metlink did some of the functions that The Met used to have, except for network planning, managing contracts and direct operation of services. The transfer of planning and operator contract management was to be a matter for another time and another government with this achieved when PTV was created in 2012 (under the Coalition).  



Conclusion

This has been my look at The Metropolitan Transport Authority. It might be a shock to realise that today on its 40th birthday we are further from July 1, 1983 than that date was from the Normandy landing in 1944. 

The lukewarm view above may surprise some so I'm going to explain further. Though less so now (as older generations died and we gained newcomers from interstate or overseas) there used to be a 'rose coloured glasses' sentimentality about pre-privatisation public transport in Victoria, especially around matters like tram conductors, station staffing and even service delivery. 

On the latter, objective data often takes second place to perception. There still seems to be a body of sentiment that regards V/Line service as superior to Metro train service. This is even though the former cancels a higher proportion of its trains, has had a sustained deterioration in operational performance and, due to generally lower frequency, imposes longer waits if your train doesn't run.   

People in every city readily claim their own as an exception in everything from peoples' sloppy driving habits to bad transport service. But I do think Melbourne genuinely has (or had) a fair claim to exceptionalism in how sentimentally it views its public transport past (even amongst people you'd think would be too young to remember). Unfortunately such sentimentality can cloud judgement over what is good and bad.  

Ranking the large Australian cities on this, Perth would be at the other extreme, almost completely lacking nostalgia. This is because only the 70+ remember its trams and its network truly was limited before the transformative rail and bus upgrades from the 1990s. Almost no one there would want to retreat to the time before then. And the enthusiast movement who might perpetuate old myths appears very small there.

Sydney and Brisbane occupy a middle ground between Perth and Melbourne. Both cities had more 1990s/2000s transport projects happening than Melbourne, and Brisbane's suburban rail electrification was relatively new. However some of their regional areas (eg NSW north coast) may still be smarting from rail cuts and more people alive remember Brisbane trams than they would trams in Perth. Adelaide's sentimentality would likely be more like Melbourne's due to an older population and a network that's progressed far less than Perth's.     

You can count multimodal fares as a major and enduring Met strength. Despite the misguided dalliance with complex neighbourhood fares, what it did achieve was so strongly accepted that late 1990s attempts by private operators to fragment fares did not last for long and were (wisely) pulled back under the Bracks/Brumby government. This gave Melbourne an edge over Sydney and Brisbane who had fragmented modal fares. 

Other Met achievements (like the unified branding and information) were discarded too quickly in the name of political trickery and operator egoism. Fortunately stability on branding seems to have been restored after the silliness from the late '90s. However it took years (through Metlink and PTV) to get back what franchising took away from us in terms of information and a workable institutional structure for network planning.  And the threat of restructuring that could lose gains that have been won is never far away. 

On the debit side, service delivery wasn't great. And the five years it took for MetPlan to come out was too long. Had Met Plan came out in say 1985 it might have been possible to lock in more of it before the money and political interest ran out. This may turn out to be a major lesson for Victoria's Bus Plan whose health on the service aspects is not the best at the moment (partly as a. it took a long time for the current government to release a bus plan and b. the 2021 plan that did come out was essentially a 'plan for a plan' without substantive service measures proposed). 

To summarise, some good thing did happen under The Met. But at many times services under it were not particularly good, reliable nor efficient, even when compared with what was happening at a similar time elsewhere in Australia. It was also weak in multimodal network planning and coordination. Hence the short answer to the question posed is no. 

Thursday, June 29, 2023

UN 158: Our part-time electric buses (Ivanhoe depot)


The state government is awfully proud of the electric buses it's getting. More and more are spreading across the network. One recently found itself at the front of state parliament. And I'm told that the party faithful rapturously lapped it up at June's state Labor conference amongst a narrative of more local jobs, cutting emissions and building the future. 

However they are only good at cutting emissions if they are out on the road providing a useful service carrying people. Although you don't necessarily need an electric bus to do that; to quote Michael Galea MLC (Hansard, 22 June 2023): 

Like for like, 40 people on a bus compared to 40 people in their cars, even with an old technology diesel bus it is still more environmentally friendly. 

So the main game in decarbonising transport with buses is making them useful to get lots of people using them. Especially if the new passengers on them previously drove. That requires network coverage, operating hours, frequency and connectivity. If you lack those then making the buses electric won't take many cars off the road.

Neither will much hyped myki replacement ticketing options nor fare-free travel. Zero emission buses and slicker ticketing are not without benefit but risk being a distraction if they are not accompanied by fixes to the network issues identified so well in Victoria's Bus Plan. In short the bus network needs to be useful, as described many times here.

Ivanhoe depot services

The first bus depot to go electric is Ventura's Ivanhoe depot in Heidelberg West. By next year it will be the largest all-electric bus depot in Australia with 27 buses. So far the roll-out seems to be going well. 

Today I'll ask whether the routes that run from this depot provide the all-week frequent service that's so important to getting people out of their cars and cutting emissions. Later I'll discuss how the routes fit in the network with surrounding services and how they can be made more useful.   

Operating hours

Firstly operating hours. Shown below. 



Just one out of six daytime routes operates 7 days. Saturday service operates on five routes but operating hours are limited with just one route continuing much after 6pm. At one time all six routes ran on Saturday but Route 551's timetable got cut (along with many others) in 1991. 

These service levels represent how most Melbourne buses were like before the Meeting Our Transport Challenges upgrade bitz between 2006 and 2010. Like routes serving Dandenong station, MOTC short-changed this depot with just one route (527) getting a minimum standards upgrade. Hence you could fill this depot with electric buses but they risk being quite poorly utilised on this network unless weekly service hours improve. 

Service frequency

Apart from operating hours and run time per trip the other thing that affects bus utilisation is frequency, especially the extent to which peak frequency is confined to a few hours on weekdays or is sustained all day (and preferably all week). The university and school skewed Route 548 has about the biggest fall-off as seen below:


Route 527 has a different pattern, with its 20 minute frequency largely holding up Monday to Saturday. However it falls off sharply on Sundays to about every 50 minutes despite it serving busy Northland shopping centre. 527's pattern is similar to busy routes like 406, 408 and 410. These had Monday-Saturday 15-20 minute frequencies but the Sunday service added under MOTC was a 'safety net' 40 - 60 minute frequency rather than the 20 minutes that these routes justified given their usage, catchment demographics and destinations. 

The potential utilisation of buses is least on Sunday where just the route 527 operates. And even that is operating at a much reduced frequency with 50 minute gaps. Given the ~45 minute run time this requires just two buses to operate. Though to be fair actual utilisation has however been better lately with buses from this fleet being used to replace trains during occupations.   

The network

If routes are well used and serves high social needs areas and/or busy destinations, there's a good case to be throwing more 7 day service at them especially if this doesn't trigger an increase in the peak bus requirement. Such an upgrade delivers benefits sooner without having to wait for ponderous network review or public consultation processes.

On the other hand you would not want to be spending big on  dysfunctional routes with poor patronage potential. Also the depot's routes is subject to the ambitious northern suburbs bus network review announced last year.  

With that in mind I'll run through the pros and cons of each of the depot's six routes and prospects for improvement. 

Route 526 Coburg - Reservoir (west)
Includes some unique catchment with housing replacing industry. But has weak northern terminus.  Shorter term: Minimum standards upgrade including 7 day service and longer hours.
Longer term: Potentially extend east to Northland to provide strong terminus in conjunction with reform to routes like 553, 558 and 567. More here and here. 

Route 527 Gowrie - Northland
Serves a major east-west corridor but part of the route overlaps with 903 orbital. Weak western terminus at Gowrie.
Shorter term: Boost Sunday service to 20 min and add some earlier am trips. 
Longer term: Potentially split route at Coburg with western half being extended north to Broadmeadows for a stronger terminus. Eastern half merged into a frequent 904 Megabus operating between Heidelberg, Northland, Preston and Coburg. This may require shared running arrangements with another operator such as successfully operates on Route 900. 

Route 548 La Trobe Uni - Kew
A potentially useful north-south route bus with a weak southern terminus stopping short of a station. Also complex midday reversing pattern in Springthorpe Estate. 
Shorter term: Minimum standards upgrade including 7 day service and longer hours.
Longer term: Make more direct with Springthorpe Estate having its own route. Extend south to at least the Ringwood train line and potentially Caulfield Station. Upgrade frequency and operating hours further to provide a SmartBus style service. This may require shared running arrangements with another operator such as successfully operates on Route 900. 

Route 549 Northland - Ivanhoe
Little unique coverage but it provides a shopping centre and train station connector. Gets average usage for a bus route in Melbourne with some high needs demographics.  
Shorter term: Minimum standards upgrade including 7 day service and longer hours.

Route 550 Northland - La Trobe Uni
Little unique coverage but provides a university and shopping centre connector. Gets slightly below average usage for a bus route in Melbourne. 
Longer term: Considering amalgamating with 551 to provide an east-west route in conjunction with other reforms that would provide a more frequent La Trobe - Heidelberg connection (eg 550 concept or extended 903 and 904 concept).  

Route 551 Heidelberg - La Trobe Uni
A mix of local coverage and university feeder from Heidelberg. Has higher than average usage on the weekdays it runs, indicating demand as a university feeder, especially for people coming off the 903 bus. 
Longer term: Consider operating to Northland via Heidelberg West replacing 550 to form an east-west route. Heidelberg - La Trobe connection made more frequent and direct as part of an upgraded/straightened 550 route or extended 903 (see above).  


Conclusion

Ivanhoe depot may have the latest state-of-the-art electric buses but the routes and timetables they run on are anything but. For example Route 527 have very high patronage potential that is stymied by a weak terminus or competition from duplicative routes. Both 548 and 551 unsuccessfully try to combine local coverage and university feeder type roles, with inconsistent running and a weak terminus also afflicting the 548. These factors make network reform for routes served by the depot highly desirable. 

Notwithstanding that, there are some potential shorter term quick wins that would deliver 7 day service on routes like 526, 548 and 549 and improved Sunday service on the 527. These would be a start to make the network more useful and lead to better utilised electric buses. 

See other Building Melbourne's Useful Network items  here

Tuesday, June 20, 2023

TT #184: How Dandenong got short-changed on buses


Greater Dandenong is Melbourne's most short-changed municipality when it comes to bus services.

Especially if we're talking about access to the 7 day service so important to get people to jobs, shopping, recreational and social activities.

First some history. Back in the 1990s the typical Melbourne suburban bus ran 5 or 6 days per week with no evening or Sunday service. Timetables bore the scars of severe cuts early that decade. These made buses decreasingly useful as more shops traded Saturday afternoons and then Sundays.

Some local bus upgrades happened in 2002 but the big change came in 2006 when transport minister Peter Batchelor introduced minimum service standards as the centrepiece of the Meeting Our Transport Challenges (MOTC) plan. These delivered 7 day service to many suburbs that didn't previously have it. That was a big deal for most people who didn't have a station, with its 7 day service, within walking distance. 


MOTC roll-out was fast but haphazard. Some areas got all their routes upgraded while others got only a handful. Neither were improvement priorities related to patronage or social need. For example quiet routes like the 701 got early upgrades, the semi-rural 578/579 got way over-serviced while busy main road routes (eg the 800 on Princes Hwy) received nothing. The 802, 804, 814 and 844 were other above-average patronage performing Dandenong routes that missed out. Yes, MOTC brought the useful 901 SmartBus and some local upgrades but progress wasn't nearly as fast as in other areas like Broadmeadows, Epping, Werribee and even Melton.   

Dandenong's bus neglect continued under the 2010 Coalition government. Maybe Dandenong wasn't on their political radar, though that did not stop politically and demographically similar seats in Brimbank getting bus improvements in 2014. Upgrades in also-safe Point Cook and Werribee were also funded under the Coalition.

Labor in 2014 promised bus upgrades in Cranbourne that had some knock-on benefits for Dandenong when these were implemented in 2016. Later a new Endeavour Hills network improved and simplified some services but not by quite enough to meet MOTC minimum standards. Keysborough South also got some improved coverage, but going from two weekday routes every hour (813 and 815) to one every 40 minutes (813) cannot be counted as a net gain for Dandenong station. 2021's bus plan diagnoses bus service issues like common in Greater Dandenong well but has yet to be backed by significant funding that would fix them.   

To summarise, the Bracks/Brumby MOTC did lots of good stuff with buses but prioritised quieter routes in other areas over busier routes in higher-needs Dandenong. Nothing much happened under Baillieu/Napthine. The current infrastructure-oriented Andrews government cannot claim much so far either. Thus the story of buses in Greater Dandenong has been one of sustained neglect with it slipping behind relative to other similar areas in relation to seven day service.

Don't believe me? 

I checked timetables for buses serving the busiest stations in municipalities selected for their demographic similarity to Greater Dandenong. Those that did not comply with minimum service standards (mostly because they didn't run Sundays and/or finished early at night) were noted. 


With nearly half its routes non-compliant, Dandenong really stands out. Frankston was the next worst, though average incomes in its less serviced areas are much higher than Dandenong's less serviced areas. This makes Dandenong's bus shortcomings more pressing than Frankston's with regards to social inclusion and equity.

The lower proportion of noncompliant routes serving stations like Melton and Cranbourne does not mean there aren't major bus service issues in those places; there are. But they relate more to lack of coverage and frequency rather than the very restricted days/hours that afflict nearly half the bus routes in Dandenong.

Dandenong's usage / service mismatch

What about patronage productivity? One might make a case that quieter routes are less deserving of 7 day service than others. Especially if you were a DTP bureaucrat who talks about juggling scarce resources to where they are most needed. Anyone who writes in gets the same form answer about the department monitoring usage and adjusting service needs accordingly.  

However this claim rarely stacks up; apart from one (worthwhile) change in 2021 when the bus plan came out, DTP lacks the 'incremental optimisation' culture of monitoring and adjusting timetables and services like Perth does even if funding for new service kilometres is scarce. 

The biggest loser in all this? It's none other than Dandenong due to its high social needs and strong usage of the bus services that do run. As an example, some of the non-compliant routes are in the busiest 25% of the network on a boardings per service hour basis. Some others are in the top 50%. This is especially so for Dandenong Station but also for some Frankston routes.

Data on bus routes that don't meet minimum service standards is below. Marked routes have higher than average weekday boardings per bus service hour (either TOP 25% or TOP 50% ) based on 2018 numbers (source DTP).   

Greater Dandenong Dandenong station: 19 bus routes - 47% non-compliant

800 No evening service, no Sunday service, limited Saturday service TOP 25%

802 No evening service, no Sunday service, no Saturday service TOP 50%

804 No evening service, no Sunday service, limited Saturday service TOP 25%

814 No evening service, no Sunday service, no Saturday afternoon TOP 25%

843 Late Saturday morning start, early Sunday evening finish

844 No evening service, no Sunday service, limited Saturday service TOP 50%

845 Late Sunday morning start, early Sunday evening finish

857 No evening service, no Sunday service, no Saturday afternoon

861 Early evening finish


Wyndham Werribee station: 12 bus routes - 17% non-compliant

439 No evening service

441 No evening service, especially weekends


Hume Broadmeadows station: 9 bus routes - 11% non-compliant

538 No evening service, no Sunday service, no Saturday afternoon service


Casey
 Cranbourne station: 11 bus routes - 9% non-compliant


795 occasional weekday trips only


Brimbank Sunshine station: 13 bus routes - 8% non-compliant

422 No evening service, especially weekends



Melton Melton station: 7 bus routes - 0% non-compliant

All routes run 7 days to ~9pm


Frankston Frankston station: 22 bus routes - 36% non-compliant

772 No evening service, no Sunday service TOP 25%

773 No evening service, no Sunday service, limited Saturday service TOP 50%

774 No evening service, no Sunday service, no Saturday service TOP 25%

776 No evening service, no Sunday service, limited Saturday service, limited weekday service

783  No evening service, no Sunday service, no Saturday service TOP 50%

789 Weekends has 80 min gaps

790 Weekends has 80 min gaps

887 Limited frequency, no evening service



Fixing it

Bus network reform in Melbourne can take ages. Because political support has begat funding and institutions that allow work to be done quickly and at mass scale, we can do major and complex works like removing level crossing and rebuilding stations in less time than DTP needs to substantially reform bus networks. However if you just want to boost services on existing routes and available buses already exist then time-lines for bus upgrades are shorter - say 12 months after budget funding. 

Dandenong's waited long enough for better buses than to be subject to a ponderous review process that may or may not deliver results. And because its existing routes are so strongly used it would seem preferable to deliver 7 day service now and worry about network reform later.

Top priorities, based on improving the busiest routes first, could include: 

* 7 day service on Route 800 to at least 9pm and higher weekend frequency. (see the #Fix800Bus page on Facebook and video below). 

* 7 day service on routes 802 and 804 to at least 9pm (would deliver a major boost for Dandenong North including the hospital - network simplification like this can happen later) 

* 7 day service on routes 814 and 844 to at least 9pm (These routes, especially the complex 814, also need reform, but, existing catchment and usage justify 7 day service now)

* Minor extended hours on Endeavour Hills routes 843, 845 and 861 to meet MOTC minimum standards (very cheap addition of 2 or 3 trips per day per route on average)

* Boosting weekend frequency on popular routes 813 and 828 to weekday service levels (reflects 813's strong catchment and 828's connection to major destinations) with some longer operating hours.

Dandenong's local member of parliament is Gabrielle Williams MP. Most of the abovementioned  underserved routes also cover Mulgrave, held by premier Daniel Andrews MP with 800, 802 and 804 extending into Oakleigh, held by Steve Dimopoulos MP.

All are Labor government MPs. Compared to if they were in opposition, that increase their access to decision-makers but may lessen their willingness to publicly advocate on behalf of their electorate.  

Dandenong is also in the South-east Metropolitan Legislative Council region, with 5 MPs from various parties. One, Rachel Payne MP, recently asked a question on notice about a Route 800 upgrade, with an answer from Minister Carroll to appear soon.


Conclusion

Dandenong has been short-changed with regards to 7 day bus service, with the gap increasing over time with successive governments diverting their limited budgets for bus upgrades elsewhere.

While other parts of Melbourne (eg Knox, Mornington Peninsula, Yarra Valley and fringe growth areas) also has sparse service that need improving, Dandenong is unique in its proportion of well used routes that don't run 7 days and/or much after 7pm. If you had $5 million per year to improve buses you'd possibly get the greatest patronage returns if you spent it all in Greater Dandenong. 

Either Paul Younis/DTP is not telling the minister that there's a misallocation of bus service resources that's dudded Dandenong for decades or it's known and there isn't the political will to do anything about it. Dandenong is known for its assembly of Volgren buses but the community that builds them hardly gets to see them running a useful service on weekends. 

Dandenong has possibly suffered from its consistent pattern of Labor voting. However old party alignments and loyalties are loosening with huge primary vote drops in booths, especially those with low income catchments and poor community services (including buses). The steady erosion of its voter base should profoundly worry Labor party MPs and officials, even though it has so far been insufficient to cost it seats in the 2022 state election. 

Down in Dandenong the (unfunded) bus plan or even electrification means nothing. 

The top need is 7 day service along with longer operating hours and then better frequencies.

That helps people get to jobs, cuts the cost of living and widens opportunities.

This is possible right now with political will and a modicum of funding to work the existing bus fleet harder.